Social workers don’t have to accept the story that’s being written for them

The profession should heed some of the advice it gives to service users as it looks to respond to government reforms, says Jenny Molloy

letter
Photo: Cultura/Rex Features

By Jenny Molloy

Having a nice cuppa with my social worker friend, casually reading through Nicky Morgan’s statement on social work reform, we were expecting maybe something about the desperate cuts to services, but not that social work was to have a new regulator, or that accreditation of children’s social workers could be mandatory.

It appears that I am not alone in being shocked at these quick, very quick, developments. Alas, I am a care leaver, and not a social worker, but I am hearing that service users are an important part of shaping these reforms.

My experience of what I needed from my social workers feels like yesterday. Social workers have a lifetime impact on kids who rely on them. I needed to feel special, cared for and about by the most stable and significant adults in my life.

I needed them to ‘see’ my achievements, struggles, pain and happiness without me having to call the office and leave a message; or, worse, wait until my statutory visit; or, even worse than that, my looked after child review. The shame at being praised in a sea of faces round a large polished table, always with the posh cups and biscuits saved only for ‘visits’, was excruciating.

Divisions

What I didn’t need was to be stuck in the middle of a divided service. A life changing service, where the qualifying route of my social workers determined whether they were accepted and respected or not. We don’t care how you qualify, just that you do. Is a baby born through IVF more or less equal than a baby born through a surrogate or natural birth?

There is no hierarchy of social worker, other than in the love and care they share with us.”

Had I caught wind of such a situation when I was in care, and in a mood, I would have used the terms ‘Frontline’ or ‘Step Up’ as a curse. “I want a new social worker, a normal social worker, not one of you Frontline social workers innit.” It would have been music to my ears to have had another insult to use when I was being told off. Let’s not deceive ourselves into believing that kids in care don’t read newspapers or watch the news.

In my experience, though, social work education is so variable, and this must not be allowed to continue. While some university courses involve service users working alongside lecturers, giving the students the opportunity to hear of real life experiences, this isn’t always the case – and how can we expect students to be able to understand the impact of their decisions without hearing reality combined with theory?

Even worse, social work academics sometimes invite in care leavers to speak and struggle to treat them as equals. This is a strange power dynamic which surely has to be passed on to their students. However, all of this doesn’t mean the fast-track route to practice should become the norm.

Further, had I heard that my social workers risked being imprisoned for not doing their job properly (as David Cameron has suggested in his proposals to introduce an offence of ‘wilful neglect’ for social workers), or even viewed as enough of a risk for this to be considered, I would have gone into emotional meltdown. My parents being constantly in and out of prison was shameful and frightening enough, but my social worker? The adults who I finally trust and believe can protect me?

Stand up for social work values

I see the current disunity in social work as ‘you are lesser than me’ within the sector. If the reforms – largely, I’m told, led by the Conservative government – are against the values of social work, hold the government to account. Go shout, strike or campaign, or maybe all three.

Because you see, social workers led me to believe, and I do believe, that you must not accept the story that has been written for you, and that you are integral to the ending. My social worker believed, and told me often, that I could and would succeed. That the fear I held most close, that of continuing the appalling life that my parents had led, need not come true.

My social workers shared with me the value of forgiveness. Sharing my anxieties, shame and anger, showing me how to hold myself together, giving me the space to grow.

The elephant in the room here is that my social worker had time. Time to be with me when there wasn’t a statutory obligation to tick off a list.”

Time to show me a side to an adult which didn’t involve the painful experiences I was used to. A role model for me to work out where my values in life lay.

Finally, I was well aware of the compassion and kindness that my social workers held for my parents, the belief that poverty, discrimination, addiction, to name a few, did not make the person, but that it drove people into places of despair and desperation, and that, for many, the ending of their story was written for them.

Jenny Molloy is a care leaver and author of ‘Hackney Child’ and ‘Neglected’

More from Community Care

9 Responses to Social workers don’t have to accept the story that’s being written for them

  1. Gilly Kay January 26, 2016 at 10:41 am #

    Fantastic, motivating article thank you Jenny and Community Care – as a Practice Educator and Team Manager I will be sharing this with my current social work students on placement and qualified social workers.

  2. David Steare January 26, 2016 at 11:11 am #

    Thank you Jenny, for standing up for a social work that prioritises time spent with people rather than with computers, and for a social work that prioritises love and compassion rather than neoliberal policies and bureaucratic procedures (cf. my Facebook page ‘Compassionate Social Work’).

  3. Liz January 26, 2016 at 11:39 am #

    This is so heartwarming. And this is exactly why I trained to be a social worker. But sadly I have left the profession because the Council I worked for were only interested in getting written work onto the system “in a timely manner”. I always gave time to all those who were on my caseload, especially parents to work with them to turn things around. Not all parents were able to do that but most were. But the most important thing to me were the children and young people I cared for, and I did care for them. Caring is not something that was valued in the Council I worked for sadly. I think that we have lost what social work is essentially about, and this article tells us exactly what we should be doing, and I for one am encouraged by this. I totally agree that service users should be at the very heart of training and in every aspect of social work development. My personal experience of being told by a service delivery manager that she had worked with the family we are now working with and taken their children into care leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. If nothing is changing then surely we should all examine our practice? I, like others, had an overwhelming caseload, I gave time to all my families and the children and young people especially, this meant working long hours at home and at weekends to try and keep on top of the paperwork. I was told by management to cut down the time I spent with families and spend more time in the office writing up……I never missed a deadline including court deadlines but the emphasis is upon the written word. Every single one of my case recordings was up to date but this still wasn’t enough. To this end I am not valued as a social worker any more. Something needs to be done about this. I wish the writer all the luck in the world and believe in yourself, you are amazing and have obviously come so far.

  4. Jenny January 26, 2016 at 6:50 pm #

    Thank you ❤️❤️

  5. Karen January 27, 2016 at 7:50 pm #

    What a lovely refreshing article. And such good advice.
    Thank you Jenny for caring about social workers.

  6. Chez January 27, 2016 at 11:20 pm #

    Thank you so much for sharing your positive experiences of the social work profession. I was reduced to tears reading your story and I am delighted that your social worker did, with you by her side, make a difference. After all is this not why we enter the profession? It’s most certainly not for professional acclaim!

    Once again Jenny, a Big thankyou for standing up for social work. Pity certain others are not of the same opinion and continue to hold the political opinion that throwing us in jail will make a difference to social inequality , poverty and abuse!

  7. steve stericker January 28, 2016 at 8:35 pm #

    We need to hear more of these fresh and insightful comments. Thank you Jenny

  8. Diane January 29, 2016 at 9:23 pm #

    Thank you so much. It is really good to hear the words of one of our young people.

  9. Mary February 4, 2016 at 8:47 am #

    How wonderful to hear from somebody who have first hard experience of having a Social Worker that cares and want to help .