Community Care logo
Loading
E-Newsletters
Inform image
You are in:   News

The Department for Education and Skills is unable to confirm whether it will carry out a review into all cases involving Roy Meadow until the General Medical Council has concluded its investigation.

Thursday 18 December 2003 00:00
The Department for Education and Skills is unable to confirm whether it will carry out a review into all cases involving Roy Meadow until the General Medical Council has concluded its investigation.

Doubts have emerged over the paediatrician's authority as an expert witness in cot death cases after his theory on the probability of multiple cot deaths was discredited again last week after Angela Canning's convictions for smothering her two sons were quashed.

Now there are fears that hundreds of families who had children removed and placed in foster care in cases involving evidence from Meadow could appeal.

Lawyers for Cannings told the Court of Appeal that Meadow had given "misleading" evidence that multiple cot deaths in the same family were "very, very rare", leading to the conclusion that the cause of the two boys' deaths in 1991 and 1999 was smothering.

The case follows those of Sally Clark, whose sentence for killing her two sons was overturned earlier this year, and Trupti Patel, cleared of killing three babies in the summer.

Meadow's expert evidence was a key factor in both cases, and it later emerged that his claim that the odds of two babies dying of cot death in the same family was 73 million to one was inaccurate and could actually be as short as 64 to one.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
More from Community Care
Trending now logo
 
 
Social care link

 

    Transcare