News

Two influential groups of MPs have called on the government to reform human rights for children and improve the protection for those at risk of abuse.

In reports published this week, both the health select committee and parliamentary joint committee on human rights have urged the government to appoint a children's commissioner for England and back United Nations recommendations for parents and carers to be banned from smacking.

The health select committee's report into the death of Victoria Climbie comes as the government prepares to publish its own response in a green paper on the future of children's services. The committee's report re-emphasises failings within the child protection system, and backs calls from the Association of Directors of Social Services for an independent, Wanless-style review of funding for social care.

"We recommend the government should commission an urgent review of the factors influencing demand for social care, and consider the adequacy of resources currently available," it states.

The MPs came up with their recommendations after quizzing Victoria Climbie Inquiry chairperson Lord Laming following the publication in January of his findings into Victoria's death.

They back many of Laming's recommendations, particularly for the registration of private fostering, the clarification of guidance on the application of sections 17 and 47 of the Children Act 1989, and the establishment of much clearer lines of accountability "from top to bottom, without doubt or ambiguity about who is responsible at every level for the well-being of children".

However, the health select committee rejects Laming's calls for a national children and families agency, describing the model as "too complex".

Mirroring concerns raised by the ADSS, the committee said it was "essential that further structural change and upheaval was not imposed unnecessarily on local government". Instead, they are calling for area child protection committees to take a more consistent approach.

The report gives qualified backing to Laming's vision for a national children's database for all under-16 year olds but says it would be a "major practical and technical challenge" and that a feasibility study would need to be carried out comparing it with the government's identification, referral and tracking system.

Committee chairperson Labour MP David Hinchliffe warned: "With the number of children coming into the country at any one time...[a database] wouldn't necessarily offer a cast iron guarantee."

Committee members made clear their "desperate disappointment" at how the press have focused only on the recommendation for removal of the legal defence of reasonable chastisement. This would outlaw smacking by parents and carers.


It is a recommendation also made in the tenth report from the joint committee on human rights on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Last year, the UN highlighted the UK's poor human rights record for children but the government refused to ban the defence, a decision the human rights committee believes is "incompatible" with the UN convention.

The committee, made up of MPs and peers, also condemns the number and treatment of children in prison.

Recommendations of the health select committee

• An independent, Wanless-style review of social care funding.
• Clarification of guidance for applying section 17 and 47 of Children Act 1989.
• Inclusion in the green paper on children plans for scrapping the reasonable chastisement defence from parents and carers.
• A feasibility study on the national children's database.
• The urgent appointment of a children's rights commissioner.
• Registration of private foster carers.
• Clear lines of responsibility within organisations for the well-being of children.

Recommendations of the joint committee on human rights

• The inclusion in the forthcoming overarching children's strategy of references to the rights, principles and provisions of the convention.
• The raising of the age of criminal responsibility to 12 years.
• Consider placing responsibility for the care of under-18s in custody with a body outside the prison service and the Home Office.
• Sufficient council secure accommodation places to allow the removal from prison of all girls under 17 from prison.
• The scrapping of the defence of reasonable chastisement.
• The government's withdrawal of its reservation to the Convention on the Rights of the Child relating to immigration and nationality.