There are sensible proposals in the Youth Crime Action Plan, not least more funding for badly under-resourced resettlement work with children leaving custody. But anyone who hoped that children's secretary Ed Balls and his newish, allegedly welfare-oriented department would come up with something genuinely radical will be disappointed.
Public fears over knife crime and sceptical children's services directors probably put paid to the most radical proposal of all: handing the £279m child custody budget to councils, removing a perverse financial incentive to hurry the most difficult youngsters into the prison system.
Given that 70% of young offenders have had contact with social services, such a move would have made sense with the right investment in community-based prevention and punishment. As it is, the action plan is another opportunity lost.
Howard League: Secure training centres top restraint league table
29 September 2008
Conservatives: Payment by results for charities to cut youth crime
29 September 2008
Children's directors reject YJB youth crime proposals
24 September 2008
Conservative plans for youth justice
25 September 2008
Phil Hope succeeds Ivan Lewis as adult social care minister
DH study reveals councils still haven't embraced personalisation
Action on Elder Abuse says personalisation is used to cut costs
Details of government consultations
02 October 2008
Private Member Bills
25 July 2008
Government Legislation
25 July 2008