I think the emerging allegations of child abuse in Jersey remind us that while social workers may find they have too much paperwork and scrutiny in the UK, Jersey shows that without such scrutiny things can go tragically wrong. Most of the allegations dating back to the 1960s in Jersey come from a time where advocacy for children must have been widely unknown anywhere, let alone on that small island.
Giving children a voice, recognition of their right to complain, treating them as a "customer" are all very much part of contemporary social work. Before this, I can't imagine what it must have been like. Surely for some abused children who know nothing else, their abuse is their "reality." This must have been even more so in the earlier days of Jersey's children's services. A nightmare from which children have no perspective on or escape from. I have read enough of those testimonies coming from Jersey now to feel as though I can't bear to read one more. We can only be grateful we have at least an aspiration to giving children a voice in their care now. It should never be treated as lipservice.