Choice has become a buzzword. Everyone from policymakers to grass roots activists is talking about choice and few people would disagree with the principle. But perhaps it is time to question whether we actually mean choice, or whether we mean something entirely different that is dressed up as choice.
For me, choice is about having the information and resources to make a decision based on having several viable options.
Many people would argue that, as all choices have consequences, the fact that some choices are based on equally difficult options does not take away from the fact that a choice has been offered. Professionals can then pat themselves on the back because they have offered service users a choice.
This is a dangerous road to go down because it is all too easy to mask coercion as a choice.
For example, with four professionals sitting in my home I was told I had the choice to accept the input of the home treatment service or be detained under the Mental Health Act 1983. Every time I tried to disagree with what the professionals wanted, I was told I had a choice but if I refused to accept their decisions I would be sectioned. Such a situation cannot be described as a choice.
Coercion was the top and bottom of it. It would have been more palatable and honest if the professionals involved had said that they had sufficient concerns and they needed to manage any isk, that they were not offering a choice, that the decision-making power was to be taken away from me.
Throughout social care there are times when professionals have to make difficult decisions. Risk management, gatekeeping and a multitude of other situations can mean that professionals retain control of decisions and actions and may sometimes have to resort to coercion. I am sure that, although it may be a bitter pill to swallow, lots of service users understand this. All we ask for is honesty and not a false idea of choice.
Nasa Begum is a user of mental health services
Open Forum
October 19, 2005 in Mental Health
More from Community Care
Related articles:
Job of the week
Featured jobs
Employer Zone
‘Solutions can’t be scripted here – you have to be creative’
Putting a team around the social worker to make a difference to families
How working in residential care enables staff to build one-on-one relationships with young people
‘We will always challenge ourselves to transform our services to improve outcomes for children and families’
‘It’s our job is to observe the child, find their voice and be their advocate’
Employer zone – showcasing a selection of the sector’s top recruiters
Community Care Inform
Latest stories
Cafcass ‘in serious jeopardy’ regarding social work staffing due to pay constraints
‘Serious procedural failings’ led council to wrongly believe man posed risk to son, finds ombudsman
‘Passionate’ social workers help council gain outstanding rating, despite workforce challenges
TV investigation aims to highlight trauma faced by families from wrongful child protection action
Comments are closed.