A society that cuts its parents adrift

    My mother is not known for her left-wing political correctness
    or a passionate sense of injustice, but both seem to have been
    fanned from some fading embers as she thrust into my hands an
    article torn from the Daily Mail and said: “It’s so cruel! Can’t
    you write a letter or something?” The report told the story of a
    couple described as having low IQs whose children were taken into
    care on the basis that their parents were “too slow” to care for

    The story left me feeling disturbed. I thought first about me
    and my mother 55 years ago, when doctors told her that I had an
    incurable physical condition from which I would probably soon die.
    They told both my parents that nurses could care for me better than
    they could. They said I would be safer alone in a hospital cot than
    in their loving arms. The long-lasting harm done to me and my
    family by this separation has never been assessed, measured,
    recorded or recompensed. It is barely understood. There is a
    primordial bond between children and their birth parents which we
    break at our peril. Perhaps her still-remembered pain was the
    fading ember fanned by the story.

    Then there is the question of the level of scrutiny and
    judgement laid upon people with learning difficulties, based on a
    prejudice which is not applied to others. Competence is as much to
    do with self-confidence as it is to do with levels of skill. When I
    took my driving test and sat next to the silent and inscrutable
    examiner, complete with his clipboard, I can remember how my heart
    raced, my sense of myself as a good driver shrivelled and the
    thought of three-point turns and emergency stops seemed terrifying.
    Despite having driven for years, I could barely remember how to get
    the key into the ignition. Few of us are at our best when called to
    prove ourselves to people who do not appear to believe in us. It
    seems that people with learning difficulties live almost entirely
    in a world of people who do not believe in them and who,
    hypocritically, demand standards of them which many people without
    such labels would never achieve. I am never surprised when such
    victims finally hit out at people in authority who have the power
    to take from them everything they hold dear.

    And parenting – whoever said it is a job for just one or two
    people, alone in a house with no support and a world waiting to
    judge us when it all goes pear-shaped? Because of economic
    pressures, most families must be supplemented by services and paid
    or unpaid carers – extended schools and play schemes, grandparents,
    child minders and nannies – in order to manage. Working-class
    families, as highlighted by the Daily Mail, who cannot afford to
    buy in their support systems, sometimes cannot cope in this
    climate. Forcibly removing children from such under-resourced
    families to be placed with better-resourced families is punishing
    people for their inequality, and does not address the real

    Two things that can help families in need are money and support
    – real support based on respect and compassion. People with
    learning difficulties have been fighting for both in the form of
    direct payments to buy in practical assistance and person-centred
    planning. This mobilises the natural relationships in the community
    to build circles of support and empowerment around vulnerable
    people. These principles are recommended in the government’s
    Valuing People strategy for people with learning difficulties. They
    seem to have been forgotten in this debate.

    But perhaps the bigger question concerns the change in society
    which is making the raising of children more difficult and lonelier
    for everyone. Perhaps the struggles of this family to stay together
    is a timely reminder that parenting is a relationship, not a job,
    and that resources are best put to supporting that relationship
    rather than trying to replace it. I guess my mother knew this.


    More from Community Care

    Comments are closed.