Government plans to introduce safeguards for people who are detained in a hospital or care home but lack the capacity to object could be subject to legal challenges, a lawyers’ group has warned the government.
The Law Society, which represents solicitors in England and Wales, said proposals to close the so-called “Bournewood gap”, officially unveiled last week, would fail to comply with human rights laws.
The proposals, which were leaked to Community Care last month (news, page 6, 8 June), could lead to people being detained for up to one year.
In 2004, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that the five-month detention of HL, an autistic man who could not speak, at Bournewood psychiatric hospital in Surrey breached his human rights.
The court listed six factors needed to address the human rights breach, including fixed rules governing the admission and detention of incapacitated people.
But in a letter to the Department of Health, the society said the latest proposals failed to satisfy these standards.
Policy adviser Tim Spencer-Lane said: “Lawyers are going to be challenging this from day one.”
The society also raised concerns that, under the proposals, the care home or hospital where an incapacitated person is living would be left to decide whether they were being deprived of their liberty.
The new measures will be introduced into the Mental Capacity Act 2005 through a bill that will also amend the Mental Health Act 1983.
Lawyers set to test ‘Bournewood’ rules
July 5, 2006 in Autism, Mental Health
More from Community Care
Related articles:
Featured jobs
Workforce Insights
- Working with perpetrators of domestic abuse: training social workers to have challenging conversations
- Extending support: the importance of reflective supervision beyond the ASYE
- ‘It’s hopeful work’: social work in an adults’ mental health team
- Podcast: supporting adults with learning disabilities and autism post-pandemic
- ‘There aren’t many roles where you get to take a child on holiday’: the benefits of residential care work
- Workforce Insights – showcasing a selection of the sector’s top recruiters
Community Care Inform
Latest stories
Regulator calls for consistency of support for NQSWs as DfE develops children’s early career framework
Leadership training programme launched for PSWs, AMHP leads and principal OTs in adults’ services
Kent ‘extremely close to capacity’ to care for unaccompanied asylum-seeking children
Frisbee Crockery: a girl’s journey from abusive home to safety in care
Comments are closed.