The mental health tsar has accused critics of the Mental Health Bill of “scaremongering” over proposals for compulsory treatment in the community.Speaking at the bill’s launch last week, Louis Appleby said opponents of supervised community treatment were scaring patients into thinking they would come under compulsory powers.
He said: “When people criticise our proposals [and say] that more people will come under compulsion that’s scaremongering.
It’s frightening to patients and it shouldn’t happen.”
But Andy Bell, chair of the Mental Health Alliance, which represents 78 organisations, said concerns about the bill were genuine.
“There are real concerns among carers, professionals, and service users. All of those groups have said to us that it will increase the use of compulsory powers and the length of time that they are used for,” he said.
Fifty Labour backbenchers signed an early day motion backed by the alliance earlier this year which opposed key parts of the bill. Such a rebellion could force substantial concessions from the government if opposition parties also dissent.
New bill revives old plans
The bill revives a number of proposals included in muchcriticised draft legislation, dropped earlier this year. Plans include:
● Supervised community treatment.
● Replacing the treatability test with an appropriate treatment test allowing compulsory treatment without therapeutic benefit.
● Giving the health secretary powers to reduce the time (six months at present) before a patient’s case is referred to a mental health review tribunal.
● Proposals to close the Bournewood gap
For more information click Mental Health
Compulsory treatment fears remain despite claims of ‘scaremongering’
November 22, 2006 in Mental Health, Social care leaders
More from Community Care
Related articles:
Job of the week
Featured jobs
Employer Zone
Making flexible working work for social workers, their families and the families they support
A safe and supportive environment in which NQSWs can learn and flourish
How one council is working to capture the voice of the child
A job that doesn’t feel like work
‘There’s a real sense of pride in our work to reunite families’
Employer zone – showcasing a selection of the sector’s top recruiters
Community Care Inform
Latest stories
Structural change in children’s services ‘no panacea’ for councils’ problems, research finds
Ofsted praises ‘strong influence’ of children on shaping services as council judged ‘good’
DoLS caseloads hit record levels
Councils boost social care budgets by £700m but say they are ‘plugging gaps in an underfunded system’
Comments are closed.