‘Do not publish in full’ Community Care and David Cameron argue that the publication of full serious case review reports will increase confidence in social workers by showing what they do and will increase accountability. But the idea that allowing the press to have access to information about physical and sexual violence towards children and women, and that this will not be used to satisfy the voyeuristic excitement of at least some newspaper readers, flies in the face of what we know of the tabloids. With SCRs especially, just about everyone referred to in it will be identifiable within their neighbourhood, even if names are not given. Also, authors would start to self-censor and edit the full reports, which are important for agency learning. What a pity there is not as yet apparently the trust in Ofsted to ensure that the published SCR executive summaries properly reflect the full report. Ray Jones is professor of social work at Kingston University and St George’s, University of London ‘Publish detailed anonymised reports’ Community Care has not argued for SCRs simply to be published in full. Instead we have called for detailed anonymised reports that concentrate on helping all of social care to avoid the same mistakes in the future. It is certainly not about revealing salacious details about individuals. The failings of the current SCR system are illustrated by this case in Doncaster and the published executive summary. The obscure nature (to a lay person) and the lack of detail around children’s services ‘failings’ have led to concerns in some media of a ‘cover up’, something that will not inspire greater trust in social work. The SCR states that failings occurred in children’s services without offering any insight into what might be done differently to avoid such mistakes. For example, if social workers were inexperienced, how should practice be changed? The SCR’s recommendations focus on protocols and monitoring activity rather than on improving frontline practice. The health service and the airline industry show that a focus on understanding mistakes and making appropriate change improves safety and confidence; social work should not fear the same step. Bronagh Miskelly is editor of Community CareAlso, the belief that what we read in the papers is reliable has been severely challenged in the past year. Remember how the media were completely hoodwinked by Karen Matthews?
Ray Jones and Bronagh Miskelly debate publishing SCRs in full
More from Community Care
Job of the week
Employer Zone
‘We want everyone to succeed in their career’ 
‘Solutions can’t be scripted here – you have to be creative’ 
Putting a team around the social worker to make a difference to families 
How working in residential care enables staff to build one-on-one relationships with young people 
‘We will always challenge ourselves to transform our services to improve outcomes for children and families’ 
Employer zone – showcasing a selection of the sector’s top recruiters
Community Care Inform
What is forensic social work? 
Intersectionality: race, gender and other aspects of identity in social work with young people Latest stories
Bill to remove social work from councils in Scotland published
Unions seek 11% wage rise for Cafcass staff after chief’s warnings of social worker exodus
Ukraine: council heads raise safeguarding concerns as UK starts accepting unaccompanied children
National DoLs court launched to handle children’s deprivation of liberty cases
Find out how to develop your emotional resilience with our free downloadable guide 
Develop your social work career with Community Care’s Careers and Training Guide 
‘Dear Sajid Javid: please end the inappropriate detention of autistic people and those with learning disabilities’
Ofsted calls for power to scrutinise children’s home groups
Seven in eight commissioners paying below ‘minimum rate for home care’
Facebook
Twitter
Comments are closed.