Ministers consider outsourcing children’s services as experts take control of improvements in Birmingham

Labour peer and chief social worker are among the experts appointed to oversee improvements at the troubled department

Birmingham town hall
Birmingham town hall (Credit: Ethel Davis/Robert Harding/Rex Features)

The government has ordered a review into how children’s social care could be delivered outside councils, on the same day a panel of experts was appointed to take control of improvements in Birmingham.

Children’s minister Edward Timpson today announced former health minister Lord Warner has been appointed to oversee improvements in Birmingham’s children’s services.

The move follows an independent review of the troubled department by London School of Economics professor Julian Le Grand.

The review found Birmingham’s plans to fix the problems were “worthy in intent” but too vague, and showed little evidence of actual improvement in services despite some of positive work by the city’s new director of children’s services Peter Hay.

“Over the course of my review I have seen considerable commitment to improve – and some green shoots of progress – but insufficient evidence of sustained and embedded change,” said Le Grand.

“It is essential that immediate action is taken to make children’s services safe, particularly around the concerns I raise in my report about insufficient leadership capacity, variable social work practice and referrals and high thresholds for identifying at risk children.”

He recommended an independent commissioner to advise on and challenge the council’s efforts to improve the service.

In a letter to Birmingham council leader Albert Bore, children’s minister Edward Timpson said he had accepted the recommendation and appointed Lord Warner as commissioner.

The Labour peer will be supported with advice from chief social worker Isabelle Trowler and a panel of experts, Timpson said.

Lord Warner said: “Birmingham’s vulnerable children deserve to receive the care and protection that they can rely on when the responsible adult has failed them.

“Over the coming months I will work with Birmingham City Council to put in place the immediate improvements needed to child protection arrangements and help them achieve sustainable change for the years ahead.”

The minister told the council it needs to produce recommendations on how to address the unidentified risk problem and strengthen senior management by the end of May. He also told the authority to work with the commissioner to develop a coherent plan for improving the service by June.

Bridget Robb, chief executive of the British Association of Social Workers (BASW), said she hoped the commissioner would support Birmingham to continue the progress it has made to stabilise a “deeply unstable situation”.

But she added: “A commissioner must not become yet another vehicle for the same political and management instability that Julian Le Grand’s report rightly highlights has long since bedevilled Birmingham’s children’s services.

Reacting to the news that ministers are considering how children’s services could be outsourced, Robb said: “Social workers in the city will be concerned at the report’s recommendation to review commissioning arrangements for children’s services, potentially not concluding until March 2015, imposing yet another period of review to likely to conclude until the end of 2014.

More from Community Care

One Response to Ministers consider outsourcing children’s services as experts take control of improvements in Birmingham

  1. Philip Measures April 3, 2014 at 2:54 pm #

    Oh dear! Oh dear! Oh dear! – as if either academics or non-social workers have the answers to Birmingham’s now systemic failure to adequately carry out its Children’s Services duties.

    Just as Martin Narey (ex-Prison Service and ex-Barnados and another non-social worker) has been deemed appropriate to guide the Government in respect of adoption – turn your life around in 26 weeks or lose your children – so we now have a similar situation in respect of Birmingham except something like a decade had passed by with failure being a constant feature.

    2 Directors given pay-offs and told to keep quiet (Compromise Agreements); a senior CAFCASS Manager brought in to oversee deletions of Team Manager and Operations Managers Posts only for the tens of thousands of pounds paid in redundancy to be wasted as the Posts (or equivalent Posts) had to then be re-instated.

    I despair – Birmingham is too big. It is ‘wedded’ to a political ideology that Big is Beautiful – as Labour’s ‘flagship’ is has been allowed to led the flotilla of ‘ships’ onto the rocks with no escape.

    Macho management; diminishing resources; inability to recruit and retain experienced staff who KNOW what works and know how to look after staff rather than bully them are all factors in Birmingham’s continued demise.

    A wholesale culture change is required but unless and until those responsible for its current parlous state are removed – or at least held accountable – then I see no hope. To pay tens of thousands of pounds more to Panels or Experts and Consultants is no answer – diagnosis is no use without treatment – and treatment is no use without the right people in place to administer, monitor and review it.