David Cameron’s mental health funding claims don’t stack up

Whether through spin, or errors, the lack of transparency on government investment in a sector it claims to prioritise is worrying

Photo: Marie.L/Flickr
Photo: Marie.L/Flickr

At Prime Minister’s Questions yesterday, David Cameron was asked about funding for mental health services.

He replied:

Cam2

Or, from Number 10:

No10

 

It’s an interesting answer, because last year the Department of Health and NHS England claimed mental health funding rose from £11.4bn in 2013-14 to £11.7bn in 2014-15. Cameron’s answer suggested ‘this financial year’ (which I’d interpreted as 15-16) funding would drop to £11.4bn – a 2.5% cut.

This morning I asked the Department of Health about Cameron’s answer. I was told by ‘this financial year’, the Prime Minister was actually referring to 2014-15. The 2014-15 financial year ended in March. We’re now in November.

I was also told the figure Cameron referred to should have actually been £11.7bn (apparently there’s an extra £300m).

So, I asked, we can report that the government now knows that £11.7bn was spent on mental health in 2014-15? Not so, I was told. The £11.7bn was just the expected spend for 14-15. Neither DH nor NHS England know yet if that expectation was met.

Yet you wouldn’t know it from the media statement below. It was released back in July to rebuff an ITV News story on figures, obtained via FOI, revealing mental health budget cuts:

MH2

The spin and lack of transparency around mental health funding is shocking. It makes it almost impossible to hold government to account on promises it has made to improve care in this part of the NHS. Promises, it should be said, which ministers have accepted plenty of plaudits for.

And a lot of this stems back to a decision to axe the only survey of national mental health spending in 2013. A decision taken after the survey revealed the first fall in funding for a decade. The survey may well have had flaws. Yet it wasn’t a costly exercise and at least offered a comparative baseline.

In the absence of any replacement, we’re left with a situation where not even the Prime Minister knows how much his government spent on mental health last year but is happy to make claims that – with a bit of probing – don’t stack up.

More from Community Care

2 Responses to David Cameron’s mental health funding claims don’t stack up

  1. Norman November 5, 2015 at 8:56 pm #

    It would appear the NHS have so overspent in the past allowing doctors to have a hand in glove relationship with drug companies whilst waiting for the fruition of the newest latest development in the form of a pill, the non addictive magic fix.
    The truth is it is all a spin nothing in the past has worked the drug giants have blundered with their development of Neuroleptics. Rather than lose millions they have managed to flood society with chemicals that alter symptoms and do little or nothing for the cause of the problem.
    Speak with any pharmacist most understand the effects of these drugs and nearly all would advise they should not be prescribed. It’s difficult to blame the Doctors as their time and resources are limited; funds have been pulled in favour of this Hugh misconception GP’s feel trapped with what they can offer to patients, looking for a fast fix.

    The system is to blame for allowing these cut backs to occur, when this is the time for intervention with an early investment strategy, creating the path to a long term solution; short term fixes create long term problems, pumping chemicals out to patients will create a long term dysfunctional dependant society unable to work, heal or support themselves, while they wait for the next magic pill to alleviate all their new found side effects.

    Psychological problems cannot be fixed with chemicals; this is a fact the Drug Giants do not want us to believe. The health system needs to be run by careers not accountants!

  2. Kerry November 13, 2015 at 2:03 pm #

    So true – well said!!