Healthcare Commission criticised for failing mental health patients

The Healthcare Commission has been accused of ignoring the
results of its own patient survey following its decision to end
scrutiny of whether mental health trusts give patients copies of
their care plans.

Although giving patients copies of their care plans is a
requirement of the National Service Framework for Mental Health,
the commission says the indicator is no longer useful for
distinguishing between the performances of trusts.

However, in the commission’s patient survey last year, only two-
fifths of patients reported having copies of their care plans. This
figure rose to 69 per cent for patients on enhanced plans.

Moira Fraser, policy officer for the mental health charity Mind,
said: “Having a copy of your plan is a fundamental part of being
involved in your own care. To remove this indicator implies that
they don’t think it’s important and trusts don’t need to

Mind are also concerned that the new indicator for crisis
resolution teams does not expect trusts to make them all available

“A crisis team that does not work out of hours is not fulfilling
its function,” Fraser warned.

But a spokesperson for the Healthcare Commission insisted that
most dropped indicators had “reached the end of their useful

“Whilst we recognise that not every single person has got a care
plan, it is no longer useful to differentiate between trusts,” he

This change is part of the commission’s wider move to cut
targets for mental heath services. The overall number of indicators
has now fallen from 38 to 28, including a fall in the number of key
targets from seven to five.

Other indicators dropped include those assessing how well
patients are transferred from child and adolescent to adult mental
health services and from adult to older people’s mental health

New indicators added include monitoring the proportion of drug
misusers who stay the course of a 12-week treatment programme.

Another new indicator examines how successful trusts have been
in reducing the numbers of people with learning difficulties in
long-term NHS residences – a key aim of the Valuing People white

More from Community Care

Comments are closed.