Last week Micheline Mason presented a strong argument against Lord Joffe’s Assisted Suicide Bill (“Suicide bill exposes the myth of choice”, 24 November). If I have understood her argument correctly, legally condoned assisted suicide could not be genuinely and freely chosen, because the choice would be coloured by the lack of real alternatives – universally effective palliative care, real choices for the poor, disabled people’s tendency to low self-esteem, reflecting society’s estimation of their worth. These, and other societal factors, would increase the chances that disabled people would be more likely to ask to die.
She states that: “Equality means we all get the same chance. We can decide to fight for better quality of service for everyone, or to fight for choice for a select minority”. This implies that, if everyone got the right service, no one would want to choose to die.
There is only so much that we as a society can do to alleviate suffering. Pain could be physical, due to chronic illness or the nature of someone’s disability – like multiple sclerosis, or motor neurone disease; or emotional, tracking the physical deterioration, pain and distress for oneself and one’s loved ones.
There are times when I have felt the sheer drudgery of leading the life of a severely disabled person. I have felt trapped and frustrated by the facts of my life: having to ask for help with every physical task, having to plan for every eventuality, monitoring my care arrangements, being stared at in public, and feeling emotionally distanced as a consequence of all of this. Sometimes, I want to be able to opt out, to stop having to think about all of these things.
If, for either of these reasons, I wanted to end my life, I would need someone’s help. And I should have the same choice as able-bodied people, to live, or to die in the way that I choose.
Disability rights campaigns are about fighting for a level playing field for people with disabilities. That should include the right to choose death, as well as how to live.
The Simon Heng Column
November 30, 2005 in Disability
More from Community Care
Related articles:
Job of the week
Featured jobs
Employer Zone
‘Solutions can’t be scripted here – you have to be creative’
Putting a team around the social worker to make a difference to families
How working in residential care enables staff to build one-on-one relationships with young people
‘We will always challenge ourselves to transform our services to improve outcomes for children and families’
‘It’s our job is to observe the child, find their voice and be their advocate’
Employer zone – showcasing a selection of the sector’s top recruiters
Community Care Inform
Latest stories
Review proposals to ‘axe’ child protection conference chairs a ‘massive concern’, warns BASW
Care review urges national social work pay scales to reward expertise and boost retention
‘Why only specialist child protection teams will tackle the annual child death toll’
Frontline’s social work qualification rates lower than other fast-track schemes’, data shows
Comments are closed.